Indexing vs. Picking

Discussion of the Stock portion of the Permanent Portfolio

Moderator: Global Moderator

Post Reply
SmallPotatoes
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 141
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 10:25 am

Indexing vs. Picking

Post by SmallPotatoes » Wed Feb 02, 2011 2:13 pm

My stock broker buddy (who likes the PP idea) repeatedly encourages me to buy and hold individual equities rather than an index. One feature is the added volatility which may provide discounts during rebalancing or even greater gains. I'm not talking about day trading, but just running the stock portion more akin to how the whole PP functions.

Feel free to track any of the top S&P 500 companies vs. the index as a whole to get an idea of performance comparison.
Gumby
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 4012
Joined: Mon May 10, 2010 8:54 am

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by Gumby » Wed Feb 02, 2011 2:38 pm

Another "feature" is higher fees and tax implications. You won't hear too many brokers pushing buy & hold indexing, because it means less money in their pockets. He has to stick to the narrative to keep his job.
Last edited by Gumby on Wed Feb 02, 2011 2:46 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Nothing I say should be construed as advice or expertise. I am only sharing opinions which may or may not be applicable in any given case.
SmallPotatoes
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 141
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 10:25 am

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by SmallPotatoes » Wed Feb 02, 2011 2:43 pm

Ha. Agreed.

But, he's not asking me to buy/sell through him. Rather just showing that increased stock volatility can be used to capture gains or buy at a discount more pronouncedly than a 500 Index.

Also, all this trading would be done in my Tax-sheltered space only.
Gumby
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 4012
Joined: Mon May 10, 2010 8:54 am

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by Gumby » Wed Feb 02, 2011 2:46 pm

Nevertheless, it's a terrible idea. The chances of beating the market with a hand-picked portfolio — over the long run — are very, very, very bad. Active investing takes on more risk for a lower expected return.

See: http://rickferri.com/books-by-rick-ferr ... -investing
Last edited by Gumby on Wed Feb 02, 2011 2:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Nothing I say should be construed as advice or expertise. I am only sharing opinions which may or may not be applicable in any given case.
User avatar
moda0306
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 7680
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2010 9:05 pm
Location: Minnesota

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by moda0306 » Wed Feb 02, 2011 2:55 pm

The 4 PP components rise and fall in non-correlation for macroeconomic reasons.  Stocks may rise and fall in some limited non-correlation, but for no fundamental reasons that you can count on to reverse and create a rhythm you can build a portfolio on.

I agree it's a bad idea.  More taxes, time, and fees will result... and probably more risk.
"Men did not make the earth. It is the value of the improvements only, and not the earth itself, that is individual property. Every proprietor owes to the community a ground rent for the land which he holds."

- Thomas Paine
User avatar
MediumTex
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 9096
Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 11:47 pm
Contact:

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by MediumTex » Wed Feb 02, 2011 4:06 pm

Also, a great industry story can be derailed very quickly by black swan-type events.

A good example is the oil services industry.  The fundamentals of this area are strong and there are many great companies in this space.

However, when the Transocean rig sunk last spring it totally changed the outlook for this industry.

A very sound micro and macro analysis that would have called for investing in one of these companies could not have foreseen what actually happened last year.

The same would have been true of the financials back in 2007.

Stock picking is harder than it looks.
Q: “Do you have funny shaped balloons?”
A: “Not unless round is funny.”
SmallPotatoes
Senior Member
Senior Member
Posts: 141
Joined: Fri Jun 04, 2010 10:25 am

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by SmallPotatoes » Wed Feb 02, 2011 6:40 pm

Thanks for the feedback guys.

I'm by no means a 'picker', and I work full-time, so choosing stocks, tracking and trading them isn't my cup of tea.

Also, good point about the unpredictability of stocks.

I'm happy watching my PP and my VP (Faber's GTAA) just do their thing.
User avatar
Pkg Man
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 401
Joined: Mon Apr 26, 2010 7:58 pm

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by Pkg Man » Wed Feb 02, 2011 8:14 pm

SmallPotatoes wrote: My stock broker buddy (who likes the PP idea) repeatedly encourages me to buy and hold individual equities rather than an index. One feature is the added volatility which may provide discounts during rebalancing or even greater gains. I'm not talking about day trading, but just running the stock portion more akin to how the whole PP functions.
I think it depends on what you are trying to do.  For the VP I too believe it better to invest in individual stocks than in an index.  While statistically you may not be likely to beat an index over the long run, you at least have a chance of realizing spectacular gains.  I have done quite well with most of my individual stock picks (I am not bragging, as I chalk it up more to luck than anything).

I would never put money I couldn't afford to lose in a handful of individual stocks, but for the VP why not swing for the fences?
"Machines are gonna fail...and the system's gonna fail"
User avatar
dualstow
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 14232
Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2010 10:18 am
Location: synagogue of Satan
Contact:

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by dualstow » Mon Feb 07, 2011 10:53 am

hey smallpotatoes

I have quite a few individual stocks left over from pre-boglehead days (and pre-pp as well). Right now, they're designated as part of the variable portfolio. I'm trying to discipline myself to direct any sales proceeds into my index funds and never into new individuals.
It's a terrible idea, like gumby said, but one can't blame a stock broker for suggesting it.  ;)
Sam Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years
User avatar
MediumTex
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 9096
Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 11:47 pm
Contact:

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by MediumTex » Mon Feb 07, 2011 10:58 am

dualstow wrote: I'm trying to discipline myself to direct any sales proceeds into my index funds and never into new individuals.
It's a terrible idea, like gumby said, but one can't blame a stock broker for suggesting it.  ;)
It's like blaming a barber for saying your lid is looking a little shaggy.
Q: “Do you have funny shaped balloons?”
A: “Not unless round is funny.”
User avatar
Storm
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 1652
Joined: Tue Aug 24, 2010 1:04 pm

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by Storm » Mon Feb 07, 2011 1:26 pm

I use my VP and pick stocks where I have industry knowledge, or know of long-term trends.  For example:  smartphones - they are all powered by ARM chips, whether it's the iPhone, Blackberry, or Android.  ARM chips also power tablets like iPads.  It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that this company, ARM holdings (ARMH), might be as big or bigger than Intel someday.  Their stock has seen a nice little rise from $5 and change in the 2009 lows up to $30 a share now.  Also, look at AAPL from 2002 to now.

Anyone that used an iPod in the early 2000s or an iPhone in 2007 could have predicted these trends.  These are great picks for the VP, but for the PP, I only use index funds.
"I came here for financial advice, but I've ended up with a bunch of shave soaps and apparently am about to start eating sardines.  Not that I'm complaining, of course." -ZedThou
User avatar
AdamA
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 2336
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2011 8:49 pm

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by AdamA » Mon Feb 07, 2011 1:33 pm

"It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that this company, ARM holdings (ARMH), might be as big or bigger than Intel someday."

Companies like Intel are very very very rare.  In William Berstein's book, "The 4 Pillars of Investing," Berstein devotes a chapter or so to this. 

Companies that create new technologies do not usually profit very much from their innovation (if at all). It is usually the companies that use these new technologies that make money. 

I know you can point to companies like Intel, Microsoft, Apple, etc, but they are rare, and very difficult to pick before they are successful.

Adam
"All men's miseries derive from not being able to sit in a quiet room alone."

Pascal
Gumby
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 4012
Joined: Mon May 10, 2010 8:54 am

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by Gumby » Tue Feb 08, 2011 6:32 am

Adam1226 wrote:I know you can point to companies like Intel, Microsoft, Apple, etc, but they are rare, and very difficult to pick before they are successful.
Even if you do manage to pick the next Apple, you won't know how much money to risk on it or how long to hold it for. And there will be plenty of hand-wringing. Your brain will try to trip you up every step of the way. It's not nearly as easy to hold on to a high flying stock as you think it will be.
Last edited by Gumby on Tue Feb 08, 2011 6:42 am, edited 1 time in total.
Nothing I say should be construed as advice or expertise. I am only sharing opinions which may or may not be applicable in any given case.
User avatar
moda0306
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 7680
Joined: Mon Oct 25, 2010 9:05 pm
Location: Minnesota

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by moda0306 » Tue Feb 08, 2011 7:18 am

Gumby... unless it's part of the VP and you have a solid PP to help you forget about your gambles and look at them with interest, but not fear and anxiety.

... another wonder of having a solid core before taking risks.
"Men did not make the earth. It is the value of the improvements only, and not the earth itself, that is individual property. Every proprietor owes to the community a ground rent for the land which he holds."

- Thomas Paine
Gumby
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 4012
Joined: Mon May 10, 2010 8:54 am

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by Gumby » Tue Feb 08, 2011 5:57 pm

moda0306 wrote: Gumby... unless it's part of the VP and you have a solid PP to help you forget about your gambles and look at them with interest, but not fear and anxiety.

... another wonder of having a solid core before taking risks.
True. But, I wasn't talking about fear and anxiety. I'm was referring to regret and second-guessing to maximize your return. It may be interesting to put a few thousand dollars into what may be the next Apple, but if you actually hit a home run, you'll constantly wonder why you didn't invest more than you did. And while it's going up you'll have no idea how to time it to get the greatest return. Should you sell at a 300% return? 400% return? 800% return? 1200% return? 2500% return? or 3200% return? If you do put a lot of money into that home run, you'll be tempted to take your money off the table sooner. That's what picking the next Apple is like. And it can be a decade long roller coaster ride. It's exciting and excruciating, but you'll almost always have some regret. It's emotionally draining.

And just when you have it figured out, something unexpected happens. It's far more difficult to maximize your return than it seems like it's going to be. Even if you have a PP, it's difficult not to get emotionally involved in a VP — even if it's just a tiny bit.
Last edited by Gumby on Tue Feb 08, 2011 6:01 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Nothing I say should be construed as advice or expertise. I am only sharing opinions which may or may not be applicable in any given case.
User avatar
MediumTex
Administrator
Administrator
Posts: 9096
Joined: Sun Apr 25, 2010 11:47 pm
Contact:

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by MediumTex » Tue Feb 08, 2011 6:00 pm

Every great trade has two parts: you must buy at the right time AND sell at the right time.

Lots of people get one out of two right; getting them both right is what's hard.
Q: “Do you have funny shaped balloons?”
A: “Not unless round is funny.”
User avatar
Pkg Man
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 401
Joined: Mon Apr 26, 2010 7:58 pm

Re: Indexing vs. Picking

Post by Pkg Man » Tue Feb 08, 2011 8:58 pm

I have come to the conclusion that if one wants to hold individual stocks, he should never completely get out of them.  If you get lucky and hit a home run, sell half and keep half.  That way you are realizing some gains but still staying in the game.  This is of course no guarantee of success, but in my opinion stock picking is mostly luck anyway, and this approach minimizes regret on either side.

Of course it goes without saying that this is for money you can afford to lose.
"Machines are gonna fail...and the system's gonna fail"
Post Reply