Holding gold in retirement accounts

Discussion of the Gold portion of the Permanent Portfolio

Moderator: Global Moderator

User avatar
sophie
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 1959
Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2012 7:15 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by sophie » Sat Jun 03, 2017 12:38 pm

Let's think about this a second. The state/local taxes won't change regardless of what happens to my income, unless I move. I don't know if that will happen, so I will assume not.

I think your accountant is oversimplifying a bit, but in the 15% bracket you're not much worse off forgoing tax deferral. Let's run a quick example scenario.

Let's say you start with $1,000. If you put it into a 401K growing at 5%/year, it will grow to $1628 after 10 years. If you then withdraw it and pay 15% taxes on it, you'll be left with $1,384.

If you pay the taxes on that $1,000 up front, you're left with $850 to invest. After 10 years, it will grow to $1,384. But, you'll have to pay taxes on interest or ordinary dividends. Let's say that's 25% of the gains, i.e. $534. So after tax you're left with $1304.

Note however that the difference in reality will be greater than this. 15% is your MARGINAL tax rate, i.e. what you save with tax deferral since the deferred amount comes off the top. When you go to withdraw, even if you're in the same bracket it's unlikely that you'll pay that rate on the entire amount. Thus, you tax bill at the end will be less than what I've calculated in this scenario. On the other hand, you might be able to take advantage of tax-loss harvesting to reduce taxes on your regular income, which could make up the difference.

So in your shoes (15% bracket) I'd also forgo the tax deferral, religiously tax-loss harvest, use Roth space for non-stock assets, and be happy about the simplification. Once you go up to 25%, though, the differences increase. I'll have to play around with spreadsheets a bit more, to see if there's a time horizon where it makes sense to stop contributing to tax-deferred accounts - that would be nice actually!
User avatar
dualstow
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 14228
Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2010 10:18 am
Location: synagogue of Satan
Contact:

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by dualstow » Sat Jun 03, 2017 12:52 pm

Something to think about, for sure. I have to take off for a bit, but I will review this in the evening.

NYC taxes, ouch.

Would you believe I fell into the 10% bracket last time around. I had a lot of non-taxable income. No, no Heisenberg activity. O0
Sometimes I'm in the 10% bracket. Wife's income is sporadic, but always low.

I'll have to look more into the 401k stuff. In the past, my main argument was that I could trade with impunity, even short term. These days I don't do much of that, so it doesn't matter. Also, the business tax has gone down here. I probably get hit more by school tax than anything else, and I'm happy to pay it. I just hope they spend it wisely. (Yeah, I know. Fat chance. But I'm happy to pay it).

Maybe you should look into an NY muni fund for your vp? Do you have a vp?
Sam Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years
barrett
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 1982
Joined: Sat Jan 04, 2014 2:54 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by barrett » Sat Jun 03, 2017 12:53 pm

Not trying to complicate things further but one also has to consider how Social Security changes the tax picture once that income stream starts. In our position (me age 58, wife age 50) we are desperately trying to shove as much as possible into Roths each year. The plan is not to touch any of those until I am 70.5 but we are still behind the curve.
DragonJoey3
Full Member
Full Member
Posts: 56
Joined: Wed Dec 05, 2012 3:00 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by DragonJoey3 » Sat Jun 03, 2017 8:40 pm

So this thread spurred me to talk to the wife about getting some physical gold and what we decided was we would purchase some from our cash emergency fund and use the Roth's as a form of emergency fund.

I'm fortunate to make enough that the situation will not be permanent (i.e. able to put over $40k in savings per year) but I think if I were not I might still consider holding a small portion of my portfolio taxable and give up the tax deferment for the security of physical bullion.

Look at it from this perspective, you have $3900 to invest after maxing your 401k for a year. You can either place it in your Roth IRA and use it to buy a good ETF (IAU/Gld, etc...) or you can buy bullion. True when you sell that ETF there are no taxes on it, but there is an expense ratio you pay every year you don't sell. If you already own a substantial amount of gold ETFs then holding some physical bullion you are very unlikely to ever sell makes sense. In the case of the $3900 you get say 3 coins, if you sell in the future you had to pay 28% collectable tax on the gains. vs 0.18% per year. This means this gold will be the last gold ever sold from your portfolio, but to me still worth giving up tax deferred room to have the security.

My wife agrees so we will buy gold now and Max the Roth's sometime next year before the April deadline.

Apologies for typos, this was written on my phone.

-DragonJoey3
User avatar
dualstow
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 14228
Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2010 10:18 am
Location: synagogue of Satan
Contact:

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by dualstow » Sat Jun 03, 2017 9:16 pm

I agree with Joey. As much as possible, buy coins but sell ETFs.
Sam Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years
User avatar
ochotona
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 3353
Joined: Fri Jan 30, 2015 5:54 am

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by ochotona » Sat Jun 03, 2017 10:14 pm

Oh yes you have to pay the Collectibles Tax on gold ETF sales!
User avatar
sophie
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 1959
Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2012 7:15 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by sophie » Sun Jun 04, 2017 8:15 am

Not if they're in a retirement account. I don't hold ETFs in taxable. What's the point? Buy physical or something like Perth Mint instead.

DragonJoey, congrats on the decision, and it sounds like a good plan. I realized I have another alternative: right now I have an automated monthly contribution to each of the 4 assets in taxable. I can stop the cash contribution and redirect it to gold, then make up the missing cash with the annual Roth contribution combined with ETF sales, if needed.

Dualstow - I'd looked into a NY muni fund, but the yield is lower than the PP's has been even after taking taxes into account, so I didn't see the point. It would make more sense to buy the bonds directly. I'll have a think about that!
barrett
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 1982
Joined: Sat Jan 04, 2014 2:54 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by barrett » Sun Jun 04, 2017 8:28 am

Thread is going in several directions at once so I will add to the mayhem. Two other things I wanted to mention about the Roth vs. tIRA/401(k) discussion, Sophie and Dualstow. I am self-employed and have to pay quarterly tax. If I look at my numbers before figuring out my retirement account contributions, I might owe, say, $4,000 in taxes. If I contribute X amount to my solo 401(k), taxes owed might come down to $2,000. So that means that I owe the government $2,000 less right now and $500 less per quarter next year. That alone sways me toward the solo 401(k) because who doesn't want the extra four grand?

ALSO, with the ACA I have been incentivized the last two or three years to have my AGI come in at a certain sweet spot for the ACA subsidy. That has meant contributing enough to the solo 401(k) to reach the sweet spot and then throwing the rest of my potential contribution into my Roth.

I don't even bother with the math because it's over my head but I'm pretty sure I am doing things correctly.
Libertarian666
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 5994
Joined: Wed Dec 31, 1969 6:00 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by Libertarian666 » Mon Jun 05, 2017 8:12 pm

Of course no one knows what is going to happen to tax rates in the future. However, I believe it is certainly possible to have so much in tax-deferred accounts that you get clobbered by RMD's.

On the other hand, I may have found a way to get around that problem. Anyone who is interested should message me privately, because I haven't gotten it cleared by my tax guy yet.
User avatar
sophie
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 1959
Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2012 7:15 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by sophie » Tue Jun 06, 2017 7:22 am

barrett wrote:ALSO, with the ACA I have been incentivized the last two or three years to have my AGI come in at a certain sweet spot for the ACA subsidy. That has meant contributing enough to the solo 401(k) to reach the sweet spot and then throwing the rest of my potential contribution into my Roth.
Excellent point. That is a pretty big return on investment, albeit one-time. Add that to the calculations, and tax deferral would win big time.
User avatar
vnatale
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 9423
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2019 8:56 pm
Location: Massachusetts
Contact:

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by vnatale » Fri Jan 03, 2020 9:18 pm

sophie wrote:
Mon May 29, 2017 5:02 pm
As dualstow observed, there's been quite a few discussions of gold recently. This question hasn't come up recently though, and I can't even remember any old threads about it.

Like everyone else, I hold a lot of gold ETF shares because there aren't a lot of options in tax-advantaged accounts, but I'm increasingly nervous about it. These funds often trade differently from gold price, and the discrepancy can be substantial. The recent takeover of GTU and the problems at some funds during the 2013 drawdown makes it clear that there's more to the value of ETF shares than gold price. Since gold is meant in part as protection for extreme situations, I'm not sure I want to be testing those waters further with ETFs. Gold is the one place in the portfolio where you really want to be ultra-conservative.

Putting all the gold into taxable, where there are much better options, would be great, but the math doesn't work out for me. I'm happy for cash and gold to dominate in taxable, but I don't want things to be too out of whack.

An option for retirement accounts that I'm considering as an ETF alternative is buying gold coins within an IRA. In most cases you'd have to open a special account and deal with astronomical fees, but Fidelity has recently made this a viable option, with fees not much higher than an ETF. The coins are kept in unallocated storage at the Bank of Nova Scotia. There is still some manager risk (i.e. you have to trust Fidelity and its partner bank), but there are fewer layers to worry about. I'd posted about this before but as kind of a side issue. Here's Fidelity's info page on its gold bullion program:

https://www.fidelity.com/trading/invest ... r-platinum

In a nutshell: buying + selling fees on amounts between $5,000 and 50,000 total 4.5%, and for transactions over $50,000 it's 2.98%. Annual storage costs are 0.5% (billed quarterly and you can pay from another account). These were lowered recently from 2-3% the last time I'd checked. In comparison, the bid-ask spread at Colorado Gold is 3.5%, IAU's ER is 0.25%, and GLD's ER is 0.4%.

Everbank has a similar program, but the fees are much higher than Fidelity's. Ditto for specialist precious metal IRAs. Frankly I'm amazed that Fidelity has been able to offer the program at these prices. It's almost too good to be true.

I was thinking I'd like to leave something like 20% of my gold allocation in ETFs, for ease of rebalancing, and put the rest into the Fidelity precious metals program as "deep" gold. Buying amounts >$50K would be worth it to minimize transaction costs.
Sophie

Read through all the posts in this topic and did not find a concluding one from you as to what you ultimately decided to do.

Are you doing this with Fidelity?

If I am going to buy gold in tax advantaged accounts this is something I should be considering.

Therefore, quite interested in any updates from you (or, anyone else).

Thanks

Vinny
Above provided by: Vinny, who always says: "I only regret that I have but one lap to give to my cats." AND "I'm a more-is-more person."
User avatar
vnatale
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 9423
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2019 8:56 pm
Location: Massachusetts
Contact:

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by vnatale » Fri Jan 03, 2020 9:31 pm

sophie wrote:
Sun Jun 04, 2017 8:15 am
Not if they're in a retirement account. I don't hold ETFs in taxable. What's the point? Buy physical or something like Perth Mint instead.

DragonJoey, congrats on the decision, and it sounds like a good plan. I realized I have another alternative: right now I have an automated monthly contribution to each of the 4 assets in taxable. I can stop the cash contribution and redirect it to gold, then make up the missing cash with the annual Roth contribution combined with ETF sales, if needed.
Sophie,

As I'm rereading the relevant posts in this topic it appears that this could have been your chosen solution?

Vinny
Above provided by: Vinny, who always says: "I only regret that I have but one lap to give to my cats." AND "I'm a more-is-more person."
Libertarian666
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 5994
Joined: Wed Dec 31, 1969 6:00 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by Libertarian666 » Sat Jan 04, 2020 6:59 am

vnatale wrote:
Fri Jan 03, 2020 9:18 pm
sophie wrote:
Mon May 29, 2017 5:02 pm
As dualstow observed, there's been quite a few discussions of gold recently. This question hasn't come up recently though, and I can't even remember any old threads about it.

Like everyone else, I hold a lot of gold ETF shares because there aren't a lot of options in tax-advantaged accounts, but I'm increasingly nervous about it. These funds often trade differently from gold price, and the discrepancy can be substantial. The recent takeover of GTU and the problems at some funds during the 2013 drawdown makes it clear that there's more to the value of ETF shares than gold price. Since gold is meant in part as protection for extreme situations, I'm not sure I want to be testing those waters further with ETFs. Gold is the one place in the portfolio where you really want to be ultra-conservative.

Putting all the gold into taxable, where there are much better options, would be great, but the math doesn't work out for me. I'm happy for cash and gold to dominate in taxable, but I don't want things to be too out of whack.

An option for retirement accounts that I'm considering as an ETF alternative is buying gold coins within an IRA. In most cases you'd have to open a special account and deal with astronomical fees, but Fidelity has recently made this a viable option, with fees not much higher than an ETF. The coins are kept in unallocated storage at the Bank of Nova Scotia. There is still some manager risk (i.e. you have to trust Fidelity and its partner bank), but there are fewer layers to worry about. I'd posted about this before but as kind of a side issue. Here's Fidelity's info page on its gold bullion program:

https://www.fidelity.com/trading/invest ... r-platinum

In a nutshell: buying + selling fees on amounts between $5,000 and 50,000 total 4.5%, and for transactions over $50,000 it's 2.98%. Annual storage costs are 0.5% (billed quarterly and you can pay from another account). These were lowered recently from 2-3% the last time I'd checked. In comparison, the bid-ask spread at Colorado Gold is 3.5%, IAU's ER is 0.25%, and GLD's ER is 0.4%.

Everbank has a similar program, but the fees are much higher than Fidelity's. Ditto for specialist precious metal IRAs. Frankly I'm amazed that Fidelity has been able to offer the program at these prices. It's almost too good to be true.

I was thinking I'd like to leave something like 20% of my gold allocation in ETFs, for ease of rebalancing, and put the rest into the Fidelity precious metals program as "deep" gold. Buying amounts >$50K would be worth it to minimize transaction costs.
Sophie

Read through all the posts in this topic and did not find a concluding one from you as to what you ultimately decided to do.

Are you doing this with Fidelity?

If I am going to buy gold in tax advantaged accounts this is something I should be considering.

Therefore, quite interested in any updates from you (or, anyone else).

Thanks

Vinny
I use GoldStar Trust (https://www.goldstartrust.com). They have fees of 10 basis points for storage and another 10 basis points for account administration, with the latter capped at $275.

They don't buy or sell, so you have to get your own dealer for buying and selling and pay those fees too. I have a dealer account with Dillon Gage (https://dillongage.com/) but I'm sure there are others you can use.
User avatar
sophie
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 1959
Joined: Mon Apr 23, 2012 7:15 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by sophie » Sat Jan 04, 2020 10:10 am

Good question....

AAAU really changed the game. I am much more comfortable with that than with ETFs like GLD and IAU that are doing potentially risky things like loaning out their gold, or buying futures contracts or derivatives. That's what could potentially cause these funds to not behave like gold in a crisis situation. For taxable I'm sticking with either gold Eagles or the Perth Mint: 1% or 2% bid-ask spread, depending on whether you make lump sum or monthly contributions, and zero storage fees. Gotta love that, and I'm not sure it's really any less safe than allocated storage.
Libertarian666
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 5994
Joined: Wed Dec 31, 1969 6:00 pm

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by Libertarian666 » Sat Jan 04, 2020 11:21 am

sophie wrote:
Sat Jan 04, 2020 10:10 am
Good question....

AAAU really changed the game. I am much more comfortable with that than with ETFs like GLD and IAU that are doing potentially risky things like loaning out their gold, or buying futures contracts or derivatives. That's what could potentially cause these funds to not behave like gold in a crisis situation. For taxable I'm sticking with either gold Eagles or the Perth Mint: 1% or 2% bid-ask spread, depending on whether you make lump sum or monthly contributions, and zero storage fees. Gotta love that, and I'm not sure it's really any less safe than allocated storage.
I think having physical gold coins or ingots stored in a commercial depository with a separation of custodian from administrator is probably the safest. 0.2% a year isn't that much if you consider it also includes record-keeping and other administrative expenses.
User avatar
vnatale
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 9423
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2019 8:56 pm
Location: Massachusetts
Contact:

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by vnatale » Sat Apr 11, 2020 5:04 pm

dualstow wrote:
Tue May 30, 2017 10:28 am
I have a Roth at Vanguard, and a Traditional IRA there, too. Long story, and I'll spare you, but I'm going to stick with building up the Roth. Don't want too many small accounts, and I mostly trade free in Vanguard.

FWIW, I think Barrett understood your post. I think where to hold gold and how much you have to hold/ want to hold are inextricably linked.

I suppose gold ETFs weren't so much of a problem when everyone was talking about rebalancing out of them. :-) Put in a little in an IRA, watch it grow, sell, no problem. I missed most of that, having started around 2010. Now that gold isn't doing so well, they're under more scrutiny, and justifiably so.

My main struggle is whether to make the pp a larger part of my total, which effectively means a bet on gold, buying more gold. What if I load up the truck and gold doesn't come back in my lifetime? What if I don't load up, and merely break even when gold soars once again?

If most of your invested capital is in tax-advantaged, I envy you. It seems like you're going to be stuck with ETFs, though, for the most part.
ETFs plus this new Fidelity plan. If you do trade coins at Fidelity, please do let us know how it goes.
Almost three years later what is the status of your "struggle"?

Vinny
Above provided by: Vinny, who always says: "I only regret that I have but one lap to give to my cats." AND "I'm a more-is-more person."
User avatar
dualstow
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 14228
Joined: Wed Oct 27, 2010 10:18 am
Location: synagogue of Satan
Contact:

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by dualstow » Sat Apr 11, 2020 5:37 pm

vnatale wrote:
Sat Apr 11, 2020 5:04 pm
Almost three years later what is the status of your "struggle"?
Dormant.
Sam Bankman-Fried sentenced to 25 years
User avatar
vnatale
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 9423
Joined: Fri Apr 12, 2019 8:56 pm
Location: Massachusetts
Contact:

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by vnatale » Sat Apr 11, 2020 6:03 pm

dualstow wrote:
Sat Apr 11, 2020 5:37 pm
vnatale wrote:
Sat Apr 11, 2020 5:04 pm
Almost three years later what is the status of your "struggle"?
Dormant.
!!!!!

Vinny
Above provided by: Vinny, who always says: "I only regret that I have but one lap to give to my cats." AND "I'm a more-is-more person."
User avatar
ochotona
Executive Member
Executive Member
Posts: 3353
Joined: Fri Jan 30, 2015 5:54 am

Re: Holding gold in retirement accounts

Post by ochotona » Sat Apr 11, 2020 7:07 pm

Libertarian666 wrote:
Sat Jan 04, 2020 11:21 am
sophie wrote:
Sat Jan 04, 2020 10:10 am
Good question....

AAAU really changed the game. I am much more comfortable with that than with ETFs like GLD and IAU that are doing potentially risky things like loaning out their gold, or buying futures contracts or derivatives. That's what could potentially cause these funds to not behave like gold in a crisis situation. For taxable I'm sticking with either gold Eagles or the Perth Mint: 1% or 2% bid-ask spread, depending on whether you make lump sum or monthly contributions, and zero storage fees. Gotta love that, and I'm not sure it's really any less safe than allocated storage.
I think having physical gold coins or ingots stored in a commercial depository with a separation of custodian from administrator is probably the safest. 0.2% a year isn't that much if you consider it also includes record-keeping and other administrative expenses.
And you pay the fees with after-tax money, and you don't drain away your precious tax-free space.
Post Reply